Stars: Delle Bolton, Will Geer, Robert Redford
Rated: PG
Released: 1972
What I “know”: Very little. I hadn’t even heard of this movie before “The Way We Were” and “All the President’s Men” drastically increased my interest in Young Robert Redford. But a friend recommended it and I know he says like eight words all movie, so we’ll see how that goes. I know he lives in the mountains, so I’m hoping he doesn’t look like Grizzly Adams.
What I know after reading the Netflix sleeve: “In a quiet performance (he speaks perhaps 30 lines of dialogue in the whole film), loner Jeremiah Johnson (Robert Redford) seeks isolation in the mountains, but he’s forced to battle nature’s inconstancy and nearly every American Indian in the vicinity to survive. Redford persuaded director Sydney Pollack to film in Utah, ensuring the the movie — based on Vardis Fisher’s novel — would have a breathtaking backdrop.”
Well, I guess 30 lines is better than eight words? I’m concerned, but here’s hoping.
First, trailer!! And I’m not watching it, but holy hell, that screen shot they’re using is not optimistic for my “not Grizzly Adams” wish.
Turns out that’s a rare embed as most of the videos from this movie are from a provider that has disabled embeds, so everything else is hyperlinked. But don’t miss the clips!
4:10: AGAIN with the overture to start the movie? What is going on? Anyway, first shot of young, sweet Jeremiah … fresh off the boat, literally, and looking clean cut save his giant chops.
5:10: Heh, heh, he said beaver. There’s his first line. No more than 29 to go!
6:34: Aw, he tried to shoot a deer, missed, and looked so sad! Poor Jeremiah.
7:31: We’re getting increasingly Grizzly here, and he hasn’t even set up camp yet. Also, if that thing he looked at was all that was left of his meat, and he’s a terrible shot, how are he and his horse and ass still alive?
8:15: This movie is honestly almost like sci-fi to me. Like, I get that it might be possible, but I don’t understand it. My four favorite things in the world are my family, my animals, air conditioning and television. Not always in that order. I can’t comprehend on a realistic level this way of living. It just doesn’t make sense to me.
8:34: So, ol J.J. tries his luck at fishing and it doesn’t go well. Then it appears he attempts to just grab a fish with his bare hands while on a snow-covered log or something over a river. That also didn’t go well. So in the middle of winter, in the mountains, with what appear to be 5-foot snowbanks on either side of the river, this idiot decides to just jump in the water in his slacks and jacket and start flailing about. Sure, he grabbed one, but then he dropped it because his hands had probably stopped working from the cold. Sir, may I remind you that we still have no proof you have a residence or a way to dry said clothing aside from a campfire? Egads, man.
Also, he looks a little Mark Hamilly here:

And this is not the face of a man who is happy to see you scavenging his land for food:

10:20: He’s literally showing no ill effects from his little river dive. He lit a fire and he’s just camped out under a tree in a howling wind. Of course, as someone who hates being outdoors and despises things like that, that could very well be possible. I’m not an expert! Just seems unlikely.
10:24: HAAHHAHHAA a huge chunk of snow just fell out of the trees on his “fire.” J.J., this might be a sign for you to head on home to wherever you came from, pal.
10:52: What happened to his horse and ass? Did he eat them? Serious question … first four minutes were him and his horses, now nada. Also, probably very sobering when you plop down to shoot some dinner and you see a man frozen to death right in front of you. GO HOME NOW.
11:57: It’s going to take a lot for someone to top Hatchet Jack as my favorite person in this movie, and he spoke even fewer lines than Redford does. I love a man who, while dying, writes a “will” to give his rifle to whomever finds him, talks of the gun’s virtues, and then is like “Anyway, I’m dead. Sincerely, Hatchet Jack.” RIP, H.J.
12:23: NO! BAMBI’S MOTHER. NO. I guess I wanted the “I killed and ate my dinner” to be a lot more abstract? I don’t know. Still sad. Also, he spent like five or six of his lines on Hatchet Jack and his rifle, so I hope it was worth it to him.
13:06: YOU SONUVABITCH YOU KILLED YOUR HORSE. I hate J.J. So much. Selfish SOB, and not even a very good outdoorsman. Didn’t build shelter, just curled up on the ground to sleep. Monster.
13:31: Now he’s asking this donkey/burro/ass/whatever to carry everything alone AND do it in like five feet of snow, while J.J.’s just tromping along on snowshoes. As a 1/16th Cherokee, I can say I’m rooting for the Native Americans in this movie.
14:30: Well now, Bear Claw is making a strong push to pass Hatchet Jack on my likeability scale. He has the benefit of being alive, but also this line: “I know who you are! You’re the same dumb pilgrim that I been hearin’ for twenty days, and smellin’ for three!” Also, Bear Claw looks like he is supposed to be in the Hunger Games or something … though I guess he is?
15:28: And this gem:
Bear Claw: You know how to skin grizz?
J.J.: I can skin most anything.
B.C.: You sure are cocky for a starving pilgrim.
Enjoy it all here, though they’ve disable embeds for this video, so whatever.
16:48: Jesus Christ, B.C. is insane. Just led a damn grizzly into his house (where J.J. was noshing on his hanging meats (not a euphemism)) then jumped out a window and said “Skin that one and I’ll get you another.” He literally just led a bear into his house and left J.J. alone in there with it. Cripes.
22:00: I love that J.J. took B.C.’s words to heart and literally fired his rifle at the elk AS IT RESTED ON HIS HORSE’S BACK. Yeah, that won’t spook him at all, you idiot. How did he survive this long? He should have been a Darwin candidate months ago.
25:35: So his horse died, then he spooked one of B.C.’s horses, who split town. At times it was just B.C.’s horse and J.J.’s donkey. Now he’s on a third horse? Is B.C. just stockpiling horses and giving them away to kindly, terribly prepared strangers?
27:33: So the Crows are basically landlording the land? Like, “We don’t like you being here but if you keep giving us stuff we’ll let it slide?” Weird.
Also, J.J. smokin’ the ol’ peace pipe, if you know what I’m saying …

28:23: J.J., who has lost 1-2 horses, depending on if this is B.C.’s horse that got spooked or a third one, just stumbled across a home with a woman outside and he lackadaisically loops the lead around a piece of wood. Doesn’t tie it, doesn’t do anything. I hope the horse runs!
28:43: Ummm those people have been scalped. Literally scalped. And I think they’re kids. Is she a teacher, or just a woman with 6 kids? No idea, but this doesn’t look good. GO HOME, J.J. THIS IS NOT IDEALISM, THIS IS TERROR.
32:48: He’s by no means wordy, but he’s said way more than 30 lines of dialogue. Maybe 30 conversations, but way more than 30 lines. I’m happy as I imagined a mostly silent movie of a guy just walking through the woods.
37:45: Everyone in this movie is insane. The mom crazed with grief. Bear Claw. The dude buried up to his neck in sand who’s still cracking jokes because he’s OBVIOUSLY insane.
42:26: Oh no he didn’t! The crazy bald one who just killed the Indians just snuck their scalps onto J.J.’s donkey so he wouldn’t be blamed for it when he’s the one who did it. I hope he gets eaten alive by vultures.
43:37: A few words of advice for J.J.: Maybe don’t rely on the crazy man who just scalped Indians to translate what the angry Indian is telling you. Annnnnnd they just discovered the scalps. Methinks this won’t be a friendly conversation.
46:33: I was kind of wrong? They were allegedly (since I don’t trust crazy man when he’s sober, let alone when he’s drunk) saying they’re impressed with the scalps, so J.J.’s all “Go ahead and keep the skin and hair of your countrymen” like it’s a thing, and then they all start whispering and Drunk Jerk goes, “What are you doing, they were honoring you and you gave them a gift. Now if they can’t find something better for you, it’s an insult” and the chief sends one of his minions out to get the gift and Drunk Jerk starts laughing maniacally.

And that is the face of someone who’s just been told an Indian chief is gifting you his daughter.
48:04: Which leads to the most romantic wedding ever!
54:27: When starting a marriage, please refer to your wife’s native language as “all that gibberish.” Even though she can’t understand you, the condescension still comes through!
56:44: LISTEN YOU CREEP. Just because you married a chick you’ve never met doesn’t mean you can lift her blanket off her naked body as she sleeps and say “Lord.” GROSS.
58:54: Holy shit, you guys!!1!11! Like literally losing my mind. I have seen this gif 4000000000 times in my life (it’s used a lot on imgur, don’t blame me) and I honest to god, on my mother’s life, always assumed it was some Zach Galifianakis skit from some unseen show.

ARE YOU HEARING ME? I CONFUSED ZACH GALIFIANAKIS WITH ROBERT REDFORD. FOR LIKE TWO YEARS. Nothing is true any more. This is the most mind-bending thing that has happened to me in … well, ever.
1:00:38: The weird Hallmark-movie type of things like the above gif (god help me, every time I see it I freak out) and his weird face while leaning in the doorway while they build their house seems … out of place? I don’t know. Just weird.
1:01:05: The cute moment where his orphan boy chops a branch off a tree and looks up to him for acceptance was really adorable.
1:02:00: J.J. to the orphan, who he has sent off to bring back “proper food”: “Keep your nose open, there may be Indians abou…” *catches glimpse of wife sitting next to him, sentence trails off*
1:07:42: No. 1, the special effects on this wolf pack fight scene are out of this world. Robert Redford wrestling stuffed animals is everything I never knew I wanted out of life. No. 2, are we surprised at this point that his horse came into danger? It’s kind of what he does. He’s Jeremiah Johnson, and he’s horrible for horses.
1:09:25: Fine, I’m 12, but him asking the orphan boy if he had “beaver scent” the morning after he slept with his wife for what I’m assuming was the first time (hence the beard burn) made me laugh out loud.
1:10:30: HE SHAVED FOR HER. I was going to say “his first redeeming thing” but he did take in the boy when his mom went apeshit crazy, so fine. But good for him.
1:11:41: Oh, cleanshaven Robert Redford, how I’ve missed you. Never leave me again. Even with the floopy hair.

1:17:00: It’s a movie that last 1:55, and you put an intermission in with like 38 minutes left? WTF, Sydney Pollack?
1:24:13: Wait, they killed his wife and orphan boy because he rode through the burial ground? That seems … slightly unfair to them?
1:27:36: Wait, what? He helps a strange woman bury her children, but he sets his wife and orphan kid ablaze in the house they built? Man … J.J. cracked.
1:29:45: HE JUST RAN AND JUMPED AND KICKED A DUDE OFF THE TOP OF A HORSE. This movie is insanity.
1:36:40: They came back for him, but they only sent one guy and J.J. dispatched of him. PS I’m no longer rooting for the Native Americans after they killed his family as some sort of payback.
1:37:16: And again! I give the Crows this … they don’t give up. But man, you gotta do better than going at him one on one. He took out like eight Crows and they saw him coming!
1:39:43: AND AGAIN with one guy, and they went after the other guy first? Why, guys? Sheesh, at this point you deserve to bite the big one if you’re not even going to try.
1:43:37: There’s a whole montage of him killing Crows who are trying to kill him … wait for it … one by one. Lordy, people.
1:44:08: OH GOD, SOMEONE GOT HIM. He’s still blinking, and there’s like 11 minutes left in the movie, so I don’t think he dies here. But yikes.
1:44:14: The shot from in front of him, with him looking up through his eyebrow, while a shadowy figure moves behind him … that’s the best shot of the movie. So good. It’s around the 1:10 mark in the video above, but it has to pan because it’s not wide screen. But in wide screen, it’s gorgeous.
1:44:55: Well, he shot the guy? But now he has a spear, liver-deep, in his gut. That can’t be good.
1:50:14: Bear Claw’s back? They’re literally living in a giant splay of land and he just keeps running into people he knows? Gah. But I’m glad to have Bear Claw back. The other guy was a poor substitute.
And it ends with him and the Crows making peace. I’m just going to pretend that was a ploy by the Crows, they kept coming at him and he eventually firebombed them just so he could get a good night’s sleep.
I was really pleasantly surprised by this movie. Had I not heard from friends (and the movie sleeve) that he didn’t talk much, it really wouldn’t have struck me as markedly less. Sure, there were long periods of not talking, but that was because of the setting. It’s not like he was mute. Also, I went on a roller-coaster ride with how I felt about J.J. and I think that’s good … no one wants to know the good guy/bad guy right away. Gotta figure it out! But coming in to a movie with Redford as a mountain man, hardly speaking, and it’s classified (at least partly) as a Western? I was not super optimistic. But I actually really liked it.
Next up: History of the World, Part 1!







-:



















